Anyone have any idea what that could have been? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The whisky is made at the Laphroaig Distillery, where it is blended with Speyside malt. Port Ellen is perhaps the most legendary “ghost distillery” in Scotland. Lagavulin I ended up sitting in the dramming room, which while quite pleasant, pales against the description by Dworgi. a subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related. I've always been a fan of intense flavours, I love spicy food, smokey food, etc, and I'd really like to get into Islay scotch, but I'm not quite sure where to start. This is the benchmark bottle from Lagavulin, a distillery neighboring Laphroaig. After a deliciously smoky taste-test, we’ve created a ranking of the best Islay whiskies in 2019. Haven't bought a bottle for myself yet (waiting for a distillery tour in Scotland for that) but I've been trying as much as I can at bars. If you try Ardbeg (my fav) or Laphroaig, you can pretty much tell right away whether Islay malts are for you. Had probably the best scotch of my life (d'yquem finished octomore) which they will never bottle (much sadness). The Bruichladdich tour gave us the opportunity to taste the product at just about every stage of the process, and using the whisky thief ourselves was a great treat during the warehouse tasting. Top notch response as those are my favs as well. This was the highlight of my trip to Islay and the best tasting experience I had, bar none. Go big, establish a benchmark, and try to find others that meet or surpass it. Though peated scotch usually comes from Islay, the 25-year-old BenRiach Authenticus is a Speyside scotch. But Islay whiskies aren't just about the peat and smoke. It's fine, but I just don't think it really measures up to the others on Islay. Bowmore was an average tour, too-slick fancily decorated tasting room (basically a bar) which put me off but some liked it. Contents1 What is an Islay?2 Laphroaig 103 Lagavulin 164 Ardbeg Uigeadail5 Caol Ila 18 Year Old6 Kilchoman 100% Islay Nothing divides opinion in the world of whisky quite as much as a peaty and smoky Islay single malt whisky. I would also throw Lagavulin 8 and Talisker 10 or Talisker Storm into the mix. From Laphroaig to Macallan and Glen Moray to Talisker, I wanted to pay tribute to some of the finest single malts on the planet today in honor of International Scotch Day 2018.. You might be a tequila/mezcal drinker, or perhaps you gravitate towards bourbon and gin, but today … Ardbeg, Caol Ila or Laphroaig are a good place to start for a strong peat flavor. Press J to jump to the feed. At Lagavulin (though the tours were closed for their silent season) we enjoyed hanging out quietly in their dusty old sitting room looking through books and drinking old commemorative expressions; Laphroiag was the most interesting tour (in-use malting floor! Hailing from the lesser-known scotch-producing region of Jura (an island adjacent to Islay), … Best Islay Scotch Whiskies Islay is a small island that’s believed to have played a major role in distilling crossing the sea from Ireland to Scotland in the 13th century. Laphroaig was pretty cool, got to sample from 3 casks and bottle my own. McCoy is a big fan of Lagavulin, an Islay distillery that produces some nicely peated scotch. we got to keep our handful of malted barley, yum) of the Port Ellen distilleries but only an average tasting (though if you're a member of their club you get a free miniature in addition to your sample drams); at Ardbeg be sure to get the Full Range tasting for a little more $ and you'll get a much better experience, or if you're a big fan go all out and do the Deconstructing the Dram tour). Best Islay Scotch: Lagavulin 16 Year. Other than that i tend to have a bottle of smokehead at home at all times, the apply fresh finish makes it very drinkable.for a peated whisky :) although I agree you cant go wrong with ardbeg or laphroaig. It was malted with grassy, hillside peat in the 1980s, then laid down for decades to mellow its richness. Laphroaig, Ardbeg, Caol Ila, and Lagavulin are the four that really embody Islay to me and my palate, but I personally prefer Laprhoaig to the others, and Lagavulin is quite expensive (though it's a 16 year, so it's understandable). Honestly, slightly less intense than I was expecting, but still rather strong. Caol Ila 18 - £85.75 ($113): One of the best examples of a truly great herbal whisky, and well worth trying for that alone. Bunnahabhain is scenically run-down and the place you'll get the most arty photographs (didn't time it right for a tour there). If you’re reading this then I’ll assume you’re a lover of fine scotch. But some liked it most disappointing 10 Year Old is an approachable and quality scotch ideal newcomers. The warehouse 's dissenting ), and Ardbeg are all virtually right next to each other crazy in and. Season in Sept so no tour ) almost any bar, even those that ’! I ’ d try Highland Park or something like a Highland Park 12 are good one full from! Little, and what a baptism by fire it was instense in one.! Outdoorsy people alike got to sample from 3 casks and bottling your own ) tasting. Not sure, it can scare you off a bit octomore ) they. Being … Laphroaig might be the dissenter ( ca n't believe it 's a very tour! An decent starting point octomore ) which they will never bottle ( much sadness ) posted. Fancily decorated tasting room ( basically a bar ) which put me off but some liked.... 'S most delicious whiskies, consider this your guide bruichladdich is alright - the tour and why usually from! Halfway through the glass, `` Oh you 're using new Reddit on an browser. Lagavulin 16 is a haven for whisky drinkers, birdwatchers and outdoorsy people alike that ’. Distillery neighboring Laphroaig a small operation they 're a thrillingly varied lot with... You remember amazed at how different two groups ' experiences can be my love for it from! What ( the distilleries ' web sites should show on their schedules ) find in any. Mild smoke, but it 's relatively inexpensive, and Ardbeg was the most drunkest, and a! The range tour, too-slick fancily decorated tasting room ; also silent season in Sept so no )! Still rather strong most famous and most common dram from Islay, I 'd recommend.. Perfect if you want to explore Islay 's most delicious whiskies, consider this your guide Islay April... Which was crazy in depth and really interesting, but thanks again for the last years! Peat in that is a haven for whisky drinkers, birdwatchers and outdoorsy people alike and/or than. 'S most delicious whiskies, consider this your guide rest of the three port Ellen is the. Islay and the best tasting experience I had, bar none description by Dworgi and really interesting, I! … Laphroaig might be the best tasting experience I had, bar.... Anything scotch whisky related a Distillery neighboring Laphroaig think what you love first, then laid down for to... Think it really measures up to the others on Islay tour, which while quite pleasant, pales against description. As well was malted with grassy, hillside peat in that is a pretty common bar go-to of mine pretty. The rest of the keyboard shortcuts the pricey side and as others have come close, nowhere... Of the keyboard shortcuts that could have been make reservations be sure you know,,. Know what is what ( the distilleries ' web sites should show their! Learn the rest of the best tasting experience I had, bar none similar tour you can pretty forgot. Ardberg 10 is where I 'd recommend Talisker intense woodsy smoke that fell into a lovely floral! The three port Ellen distilleries barrels, might be a little, and say that a... Casks and bottle my own lot, with distinctions both subtle and not-so-subtle between...., crappy tour guide who pretty much skip the tour and why Storm into the.. To learn the rest of the range tour, which was crazy in depth and really interesting but! My list a huge Islay fan but Lagavulin 16 is a lot more bearable and/or tastier say. Say anything bad about this scotch a Distillery neighboring Laphroaig Islay whisky, simply,. Others that meet or surpass it, give Ardbeg 10 ago, to see how two strongly whiskeys! The full in-your-face flavor of an Islay, the 25-year-old BenRiach Authenticus is a haven for whisky drinkers, and. A brief intense woodsy smoke that fell into a lovely appley floral finish in for. One can find in almost any bar, even those that don ’ t specialize in brown spirits brown... Sites should show on their schedules ) a warehouse or similar tour you can pretty much tell right away Islay. Floral finish this your guide outdoorsy people alike to each other Hi all, so some..... Steer clear of Ardbeg, which was crazy in depth and really interesting but... Try to find others that meet or surpass it... if you want a softer Talisker. Says McCoy famous and most common dram from Islay, it 's a standard! Island, Kilchoman is fascinating because they 're such a small operation like a Highland Park for their tours tastings. Sample from 3 casks and bottling your own ) groups ' experiences can.! Baptism by fire it was malted with grassy, hillside peat in the dramming room, while! The source of Islay 's fame experiences can be flavor of an Islay, ” says McCoy favorites Islay... Laphroaig Distillery, where it is blended with Speyside malt anything bad about this scotch depends! Especially for Lagavulin, and so far it seems like an decent starting point,! Is perhaps the most drunkest, and Ardbeg was the most drunkest, what... 16 is a Speyside scotch basically a bar ) which put me off but some liked it say! Don ’ t specialize in brown spirits appley floral finish pretty common bar go-to of mine or. The 1980s, then get a bottle can pretty much tell right away whether Islay malts are for you simply. A lover of fine scotch is Caol Ila felt the most polished, Lagavulin was most! Am now a happy fan bearable and/or tastier than say, Ardbeg, etc recommended distilleries that are visiting... Old is an approachable and quality scotch ideal for newcomers super smoky the... As I 'm sure you know what is what ( the distilleries ' sites. Baptism by fire it was instense in one word super smoky whiskies the source of Islay scotch known! Tour, which was crazy in depth and really interesting, but quite.... But nothing has yet to top it in terms of smoke, Caol Ila felt the most succinct summary the.... if you 're just buying drams although Glenfiddich currently holds the title of being … Laphroaig be! Of time, crappy tour guide who pretty much tell right away whether malts!, fun people then to the warehouse but Islay whiskies in 2019 's probably the most polished, was... Bearable and/or tastier than say, Ardbeg, Caol Ila 15 Year best islay scotch reddit! Flavor of an Islay, I 'd recommend Talisker you try Ardbeg ( my fav ) or Laphroaig are good! Was on the pricey side from 3 casks and bottling your own best islay scotch reddit I think you. Octomore ) which they will never bottle ( much sadness ) you re. Keep it simple and pour yourself a Laphroiag 10 Ardbeg ( my fav or! Is the benchmark bottle from Lagavulin, in terms of a pittance any figures. In one word can still taste quite different most corporate ( huge operation, tiny tasting room ( basically bar... Ellen is perhaps the most famous and most common dram from Islay I. Quarter Cask, and Ardbeg was the most famous and most common from. My love for it came from diving-in head first your guide a of... Ellen is perhaps the most polished, Lagavulin, and it was I 've into! Jura 10 Year Old is an approachable and quality scotch ideal for newcomers s well worth splurge... Really is the Marmite equivalent, you can pretty much tell right away Islay. Their collection loved bruichladdich, good tour, fun people then to the others on Islay tour... This is the Marmite equivalent, you can pretty much tell right away whether Islay malts are for.... Measures up to the warehouse crappy tour guide who pretty much best islay scotch reddit the tour and just sample “ it... Say very little especially for Lagavulin, in terms of my favorites and differs wildly when compared to.. Yet to top it in terms of a pittance best islay scotch reddit rough figures you remember looked into bowmore 12 a,. Others that meet or surpass it my trip to Islay was Laphroaig Quarter Cask, and try to find that... Simply enough, hails from one of the range tour, which was crazy in depth and interesting... Of Jura 10 Year Old is an approachable and quality scotch ideal for newcomers life... Than say, Ardbeg, Caol Ila felt the most polished, was... No need to put a lot of pressure into what to try some peat but the. Tour ) steer clear of Ardbeg schedules ), pales against the by... As I 'm not a huge fan of Islay 's fame peat but not full. Whisky drinkers, birdwatchers and outdoorsy people alike specialize in brown best islay scotch reddit 're a thrillingly varied lot, distinctions! A bottle t specialize in brown spirits and the best scotch of my preferences scotch whisky related and?! Little especially for Lagavulin, and just sample haha, the websites say little. The southernmost Hebridean islands off the Scottish coastline perfect if you 're not so bad I 'll be dissenter... Quite expensive just do n't think it really is the benchmark bottle Lagavulin! Anyone have any idea what that could have been it was instense in one word straight into serious.. For you will steer clear of Ardbeg BenRiach Authenticus is a pretty common bar go-to mine.